PLEASE NOTE: All bidding for the auction currently underway
at our new website at
Auction End Date
12/20/2005 10:54:30 AM (mm/dd/yyyy)
[Polemic - Only Ed.] Nissan Schidhoff
This listing is an independent item not part of any collection
Only edition. 38 pp., 193:111 mm., light age staining, wide margins, stamps. A very good copy bound in modern half cloth boards.
This pamphlet relates to the celebrated court case against Leopold Kompert (1822-1866), the German Jewish writer and journalist based in Vienna who was also co-editor of the Jahrbuch fuer Israeliten. The case centered around his publication in the 1863/64 jahrbuch of an article by Heinrich Graetz (1817-1891), the renowned Jewish historian, in which, according to the public prosecutor, ‘the teaching about the Messiah of the Jewish Orthodox church was offended’. Isaac Hirsch Weiss (1815-1905), the haskalah scholar and author of works on the ‘Oral Law’, took a prominent part in the Kompert trial, publishing a pamphlet entitled Netzach Yisrael (Vienna, 1864) in support of the testimony of Lazar Horowitz (1803-1868) and Isaac Noah Mannheimer (1793-1865) – both of them Jewish religious leaders in Vienna (orthodox and reform respectively). The two of them had defended Graetz in court with regard to his views on the Jewish belief in the Messiah. This booklet was written by R. Schidloff (d.1894), an orthodox traditionalist, to deliver a point-by-point refutation of Weiss’s pamphlet. Kompert was eventually found guilty and fined for the article’s publication.
מכתב ... נגד המחברת נצח ישראל (הכינו אייזיק הירש ווייס ... נדפס בווען [תרכ"ד]) מידידי... מהו' ניסן שידלאף בק"ק קאללין. והוצאתיו לאור ... עזריאל פאללאק ש"ץ בק"ק אייזענשטאדט ... עמ' [ג]-ז: מכתם על ספר נצח ישראל.
JE; EJ; CD-EPI 0169904
(Click thumbnail to view full size image)
Kind of Judaica