[Book List]  

PLEASE NOTE: All bidding for the auction currently underway
at our new website at www.virtualjudaica.com/

Bidding Information
Lot #    26146
Auction End Date    3/23/2010 10:11:00 AM (mm/dd/yyyy)
Title Information
Title (English)    Commentary of Rabbenu Asher on Sukkah
Title (Hebrew)    תוספות הרא'ש
Author    [First Ed.] R. Asher ben Jehiel
City    Jerusalem
Publisher    Samuel haLevi Zuckerman
Publication Date    1903
Collection Information
Independent Item    This listing is an independent item not part of any collection
Description Information
   First edition of commentary. [4], 42; 11 ff., folio, 199:160 mm., wide margins, usual light age staining. A very good copy bound in contemporary marbled paper over boards, rubbed.
   Novellae of Rabbenu Asher (Rosh, R. Asher ben Jehiel) on tractate Sukkah accompanied by the commentaries of R. Elijah Marder (1836-1917) of Zhidkov (Tarnobrzeg). The novella is herewith prited for the first time based on a manuscript in the editor's possession.

Rabbenu Asher (Rosh, R. Asher ben Jehiel, c. 1250–1327) was one of the most prominent of the Medieval German talmudists. His first teachers were his father, one of the Hasidei Ashkenaz, who was a follower of Judah b. Samuel he-Hasid, and his elder brother. He spent some time in France, apparently in Troyes and then lived in Cologne and Coblenz. From there he moved to Worms, where his teacher Meir b. Baruch of Rothenburg had been appointed rabbi in 1281. Meir esteemed his pupil, and appointed him a member of the local bet-din. After the imprisonment of Meir, Asher became the acknowledged leader of German Jewry and headed the unsuccessful efforts to obtain his master's release, toward which he was prepared to contribute a considerable portion of his assets. He distinguished himself for his activities during the period of the Rindfleisch massacres (1298), and for his decisions on matters arising from the resulting disruption of family and communal life. Fearing a similar fate to that of Meir of Rothenburg, Asher left Germany in 1303. The following year, he reached Barcelona, via north Italy and Provence, where he was welcomed with great honor by Solomon b. Abraham Adret. In 1305 he accepted the position of rabbi in Toledo. His son, Judah, relates that shortly thereafter, Asher turned down a request of the German authorities that he return to his native country, for which they were prepared to provide an imperial letter of safe-conduct and an escort of 50 soldiers.

Asher was drawn into the contemporary conflict concerning the study of philosophy. In Provence he had found only "isolated individuals" engaged in exclusive study of the Torah, which fact he attributed to the widespread study of philosophy. From Barcelona he sent a letter of encouragement to Abba Mari Astruc, a leader of the opponents of philosophy. Alive to the danger of discord, he proposed an intercommunal conference to reconcile the opposing views (Minhat Kena'ot, 51). When Solomon Adret proposed a ban on the study of philosophy by anyone under the age of 25, Asher, already in Toledo, influenced the local leaders to support this ban. His vast influence and moral stature enabled him to overcome the difficulties which he encountered in those activities, and his spiritual influence was acknowledged even by the Castilian queen, Maria de Molina.

His responsa sometimes reflect the modesty and humility that typified the German school, and at others, the firmness and authority of one speaking in the name of the supreme political and judicial body of Spanish Jewry. Asher introduced into Spain the system of study of the tosafists and tried to establish a German minhag. He is regarded as one of the outstanding halakhic authorities who put the final seal to the work of the German and French codifiers, joining to it the Spanish halakhah. True to the methods of the tosafists, he subjected the statements of the rishonim and geonim to a critical examination and did not hesitate to disagree with them whenever talmudic sources did not support their view and conclusions. Virtually all the communities of Spain referred their problems to him and students flocked to his yeshiva from all Europe, including Russia. When he encountered matters not specifically prohibited in the Torah, Asher was prepared to abandon his own opinion in the face of strong opposition, particularly for the sake of peace, but he never hesitated from taking a strong stand against undesirable developments in the communal life.

His halakhic works are: (1) Piskei ha-Rosh (also called Hilkhot ha-Rosh, Sefer ha-Asheri), modeled on that of Alfasi. In it he sums up the decisions of the earlier codifiers and commentators. (2) Responsa (Constantinople, 1517). The extant collection numbers over 1,000 responsa, arranged in 108 chapters, subdivided into sections. They are of the utmost significance in the study of halakhic development and give an insight into the cultural life of Spanish and German Jewry. (3) Commentary on the Mishnayot to the orders of Zera'im being mainly an abridgment of the commentary of Samson b. Abraham of Sens to these orders. Asher's piety and exemplary conduct are reflected in his celebrated work, known variously as Hanhagot ha-Rosh, Orhot Hayyim and Zavva'at ha-Rosh (Venice, 1579). It includes 131 ethical sayings grouped for each of the six weekdays, in which he details rules of conduct for a Jew in his private, family, and public life, and in relation to Jews and Gentiles. He demands integrity, courtesy, and sincerity in dealings with Gentiles. In 1965 the Institute for Research in Jewish Law of the Hebrew University published a comprehensive index to Asher's responsa. The index includes lists of all biblical, talmudic, and post-talmudic sources quoted in the responsa.

Paragraph 2    על מסכת סוכה מאת רבנו אשר בן רבנו יחיאל ז"ל ... יוצא לאור עתה פעם ראשונה ע"פ כת"י יחידי בעולם עם זר זהב סביב לו בשם תוספי תוספות כולל באור ... והערות והארות ... עליו מאת ... ר' שלמה אהרן ווערטהיימער ... נדפס עתה בהשתדלותי ובהוצאת כספי, ובסופו חברתי ... שו"ת מהגאון רבנו יצחק מפוזנא ז"ל רבו של רבנו מגן אברהם ז"ל שהי' עד כה בכת"י ... אני הק' אלי' מארדר מדזיקוב גאליציען כעת פעה"ק ירושלם ...

דף [4, א]: דברי אליהו. הקדמת המו"ל, אליהו מארדער. יא דף: באר יצחק, תשובות ר' יצחק מפוזנא (סי' לז-מא); דברי אליהו, חידושים, מאת ר' אליהו מארדר; תשובה, מאת ר' אליהו דוד ראבינאוויץ תאומים.

עם הסכמות ר' חיים חזקיאו מדיני, חברון, אלול תרס"ג; ר' שלום מרדכי הכהן [שוואדראן], ברעזען, כה מנחם-אב תרס"ג; ר' אלי' דוד ראבינאוויץ תאומים, ירושלים, יז מנחם-אב תרס"ג; ר' יצחק ליב סופר, דראהביטש, כ סיון תרס"ג; ר' חזקי' שבתי, יפו; ר' אהרן הכהן ארלאינסקי, פתח תקוה, כב סיון תרס"ג.

   EJ; CD-EPI 0112400
Associated Images
2 Images (Click thumbnail to view full size image):
  Order   Image   Caption
  1   Click to view full size  
  2   Click to view full size  
Listing Classification
20th Century:    Checked
Israel:    Checked
Novellae:    Checked
First Editions:    Checked
Language:    Hebrew
Manuscript Type
Kind of Judaica